BAY STREET THEATER ANNOUNCES FULL CASTS

“DECEIVED” AND “BONNIE & CLYDE”

TWO THRILLING SUMMER PRODUCTIONS TO IGNITE THE STAGE

*************************

Bay Street Theater is proud to unveil the complete cast and creative teams for two of this summer’s most daring theatrical events: the noir psychological thriller Deceived and the pulse-pounding musical Bonnie & Clyde. These back-to-back productions promise audiences an unforgettable season of high-stakes drama, dark secrets, and dangerous love – all delivered with Bay Street’s signature intimacy and edge.

Directed by Tony Award nominee Sheryl Kaller, Deceived is a chilling new adaptation of Patrick Hamilton’s Gaslight, reimagined by playwrights Johnna Wright and Patty Jamieson. The cast features Mary Bacon (Coal Country, Boardwalk Empire), Briana Carlson-Goodman (Les Misérables, Hair), Olivia Cygan (Doubt, Steppenwolf Theatre), and Sam Gravitte (Wicked). Scenic design is by Jason Ardizzone-West, with costumes by Devario D. Simmons, lighting by Reza Behjat, and sound design and original music by Jane Shaw.

Following Deceived, the seductive and explosive musical Bonnie & Clyde blazes onto the Bay Street stage, directed by Artistic Director Scott Schwartz. With music by Frank Wildhorn, lyrics by Don Black, and a book by Ivan Menchell, this thrilling production stars Lyda Jade Harlan as Bonnie and Charlie Webb as Clyde. The cast also includes Nick Bailey as Buck, Ashley Alexandra as Blanche, and Amy Bodnar, Jeremy Webb, Gisela Aduisa, Kathy Deitch, Anargha Pal, Vishal Vaidya, and understudies Mackenzi Germain, and Anthony Costello. Choreography is by Emily Maltby, orchestrations by Patrick Sulken, and costumes by Ashley Soliman.

————————

Photo: Olivia Cygan as Bella in Deceived 

—————————

“These shows are both gripping and fearless,” said Schwartz. “They explore obsession, survival, and identity in wildly different but equally thrilling ways — and we can’t wait to share them with our audiences.” 

—————————

Deceived begins previews June 24 and runs through July 20.

Bonnie & Clyde follows, running July 29 through August 24.

Tickets are on sale now at www.baystreet.org 

or by calling the Box Office at 631-725-9500.

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Bay Street Theater’s 2025 Mainstage Season

The 2025 Mainstage Season at Bay Street Theater is a curated journey through love, doubt, and defiance. Under the artistic direction of Scott Schwartz, this year’s lineup offers a deliberate emotional arc—beginning with intimacy, deepening into unease, and closing with impact. From the quiet resonance of Bob & Jean: A Love Story by Pulitzer Prize and Tony Award winner Robert Schenkkan, to the psychological precision of DECEIVED, a new adaptation of Gaslight, to the genre-defying momentum of Bonnie & Clyde: The Musical, each production has been selected for its power to move and provoke. Together, they reflect Bay Street’s belief that great theater doesn’t just entertain. It transforms.

—————————–

Bay Street Theater

The Bay Street Theater and Sag Harbor Center for the Arts is a year-round nonprofit professional theater and community cultural center. Its mission is to innovate, educate, and entertain through the performing arts while bringing people together in celebration of creativity and connection. It serves as a cultural gathering place, an educational resource, and a home for artists and audiences alike.

——————————

Our Sponsors, our story. They make it all possible.

As a nonprofit public theater, Bay Street Theater relies on the generosity of sponsors who believe in the power of the arts to inspire and connect. Their support fuels Mainstage productions featuring world-class directors, actors, and playwrights on our stage in Sag Harbor Village, on the East End of Long Island. It also drives our education programs, Music Mondays, comedy nights, film screenings, and much more.

Help sustain Bay Street’s mission by supporting this week’s featured sponsors: AARP Long Island, Advantage Title, Altitude Jet, Ann Ciardullo & Keith Green, Ben Krupinski Builder, Build Labs, Corcoran, Maggio Environmental, Mala Sander + Team, Peconic Landing, RISK Strategies, Sotheby’s International Realty, The Agency, Unlimited Earth Care, and Weber & Grahn.

Learn more about supporting Bay Street Theater here.

631-725-9500

One Long Wharf, Sag Harbor Village

——————

Box Office Hours

Daily, 11am-5pm (or showtime.)

Open 30 Mins Before Showtime

Lobby Bar Open One Hour Before Curtain

——————

——————————–

===================================================

AAQ / Resource: Stelle Lomont Rouhani Architects

===============================================

AAQ / Resource: Ben Krupinski Builder

===================================================

AAQ / Resource: Riverhead GMC

___________________________________________________